Skirt proportions come from its relationship with the top and shoes, not just a length category. Start with the actual waistband position and cut: fitted, flared and pleated designs create different lines. Choose your intended effect without one compulsory body-shape rule.
Set the waistband before comparing
Wear the skirt at the position intended by its cut and check comfort. Do not move it higher or lower only for a photograph if you will not wear it there. Then compare the hemline. Notice asymmetry or a slit that changes the view while walking.
Compare the top’s hemline
Review a tucked and loose top where its cut permits both. With a longer shirt or blazer, see where its hem crosses the skirt. A narrow top is not compulsory with a wide skirt. Compare length and volume separately by changing one element at a time.
Add the intended shoes
Try the shoes you will wear and look at the transition from skirt hem to footwear. With boots, include shaft height; a visible gap or overlapping lines can be deliberate. Do not choose a different heel simply to satisfy a rigid ratio. Check walking freedom.
Check movement and finishing
Sit, walk and review the waistband after movement. Add the outer layer and compare the outfit after removing it too. Before shortening, discuss pleats, lining, slit and decorative finish with a tailor. The new length should account for these features, not just a line chosen in the mirror.